Why We Keep Falling for the Same People: Attachment, Attraction, and Unconscious Patterns
Updated: Nov 10
Understanding Relationship Patterns: A Journey Toward Healing
By Elaine Skoulas, LMFT

In graduate school, I had a professor who said that for the first six months of dating, we are holograms to one another. A hologram is a three-dimensional image created with light that appears real, even though what we see is a projection. Early dating works much the same way. We know fragments of another person and fill in the rest with our hopes, desires, expectations, and previous relational experiences.
As we get to know someone, the projection gradually gives way to a more complete person. Sometimes what emerges is even more compelling than what we imagined. Other times, we confront familiar disappointments, emotional distance, or dynamics we thought we had left behind. Why do certain relationship patterns seem to repeat, even when we consciously want something different?
The Unconscious Pull of Familiar Relationships
Sigmund Freud described repetition compulsion as the tendency to repeat earlier experiences, including painful ones, rather than simply remember them. From a psychodynamic perspective, repetition may reflect an unconscious attempt to revisit an unresolved experience, perhaps with the hope of finally achieving a different outcome. In relationships, this can look like repeatedly becoming attracted to people who are emotionally unavailable, feeling responsible for another person’s emotional well-being, or working increasingly hard to secure affection that remains uncertain.
These patterns do not necessarily reflect conscious preferences. We may genuinely want consistency, closeness, and mutuality while finding ourselves drawn toward relationships that evoke something quite different. Familiarity can exert a powerful influence on attraction. What feels compelling is not always what feels good, and what feels familiar is not necessarily what we consciously desire.
How Attachment Shapes Attraction
Attachment theory, developed by John Bowlby and expanded through the research of Mary Ainsworth and others, helps explain how early relationships influence our expectations of closeness, emotional availability, and dependence. Through repeated experiences with caregivers, children develop internal working models of themselves and others. These models shape expectations about whether emotional needs will be met, whether closeness is safe, and what someone must do to maintain connection.
Importantly, children adapt differently to their environments. Two children growing up with emotionally unavailable caregivers may develop very different strategies. One might become especially attentive to signs of disconnection, seeking reassurance and closeness. Another might learn to minimize emotional needs and rely heavily on independence. Both strategies can be understood as adaptations to the relational environments in which they developed.
Attachment research commonly describes secure, anxious, avoidant, and disorganized patterns. Yet these categories are not fixed identities. Attachment experiences continue throughout life, and our responses to intimacy are shaped by the particular relationships we inhabit. Someone who generally feels secure may become anxious in a relationship marked by inconsistency. Someone who tends to withdraw may become more emotionally available in a relationship where closeness feels safe. The question is not simply what attachment style a person has, but what happens between two people.
When Pursuing and Withdrawing Become a Pattern
One familiar relational dynamic involves a person seeking greater closeness while the other creates distance. The more one pursues, the more the other withdraws. Each person’s response can intensify the other’s sense of threat. For the person seeking connection, distance may activate fears of rejection or abandonment. For the person withdrawing, requests for closeness may evoke fears of being overwhelmed, controlled, or losing autonomy.
Neither response necessarily reflects a lack of care. Both may be attempts to protect against emotional vulnerability. But understanding a pattern is different from accepting its consequences indefinitely. Someone can have a painful attachment history and still be unable or unwilling to participate in the kind of relationship another person wants. Compassion for someone’s adaptations does not require abandoning our own needs.
Chemistry, Projection, and Relational Capacity
Attraction is complex. It can involve desire, identification, admiration, familiarity, fantasy, and unconscious associations that are difficult to explain. Sometimes intense chemistry emerges alongside uncertainty. We may become preoccupied with someone whose attention is inconsistent, experiencing the anticipation of connection as part of the attraction itself.
At other times, we are drawn to qualities that genuinely matter to us: kindness, integrity, generosity, curiosity, and consideration. Yet even admirable character traits do not automatically translate into emotional availability or the capacity to sustain a mutually satisfying relationship. Relational capacity becomes visible over time. It emerges in how two people communicate, respond to vulnerability, navigate disappointment, repair misunderstandings, and make room for each other’s experiences.
A relationship is not simply the meeting of two compatible personalities. It is something two people continually create through their participation. As the early projections begin to fade, we have an opportunity to encounter the person who is actually there, rather than the person we hoped they might become.
How These Patterns Emerge in Therapy
Our attachment experiences do not remain confined to romantic relationships. They can also emerge in friendships, families, professional relationships, and psychotherapy itself. In Attachment in Psychotherapy, David Wallin explores how attachment patterns influence the therapeutic relationship. A client may worry about disappointing the therapist, hesitate to express anger, fear becoming dependent, or struggle to trust the therapist’s consistency.
Someone who learned to minimize their needs may find it difficult to receive care, even when care is available. Someone accustomed to unpredictable relationships may remain vigilant for signs of rejection, even within a consistent therapeutic relationship. These experiences offer important information about how a person has learned to navigate connection. Rather than treating such responses as problems to eliminate, therapy can approach them with curiosity. The ways we protect ourselves often make sense when understood in the context of our histories.
Developing Earned Secure Attachment
Attachment patterns can change. The concept of earned secure attachment describes the possibility of developing greater security through reflection, meaningful relationships, and new emotional experiences, even when early attachment experiences were difficult. Psychotherapy can provide one setting in which this becomes possible.
Consistency, predictable boundaries, emotional availability, and the therapist’s genuine regard for the client help create a relationship in which familiar expectations can gradually be reconsidered. Carl Rogers emphasized the importance of empathy, congruence, and unconditional positive regard in supporting therapeutic change. This does not mean the therapeutic relationship is free from misunderstandings. Ruptures, moments of disconnection or misattunement, are inevitable in human relationships. What matters is whether they can be acknowledged and repaired.
For someone who has learned that conflict leads to abandonment, experiencing disagreement without the loss of connection can be particularly meaningful. These changes are not solely intellectual. Attachment experiences are also felt in the body, through patterns of tension, vigilance, withdrawal, longing, or relief. Therapy can help someone recognize these responses as they arise and gradually develop more flexibility in how they respond. Over time, familiar relational experiences need not dictate the same choices.
From Repetition to Choice
Understanding our attachment histories does not mean eliminating attraction, vulnerability, or uncertainty from relationships. Nor does it mean that every difficult relationship is a repetition of childhood. It means becoming more curious about what draws us toward certain people, what we do when connection feels threatened, and what we may be overlooking in the process.
Awareness creates room to distinguish longing from reciprocity, familiarity from emotional safety, and the hope of someone’s potential from their actual participation in a relationship. We may not always choose whom we feel attracted to, but we can become more intentional about the relationships we continue to invest in.
Conclusion: Embracing Change and Growth
As we navigate our relationships, it’s essential to remember that change is possible. By exploring our attachment patterns, we can foster healthier connections. This journey requires patience and self-compassion. It’s okay to seek help along the way.
If you would like to better understand your attachment experiences and recurring relationship patterns, schedule a consultation call with me to discuss how we can work together.
References
Ainsworth, M. D. S., Blehar, M. C., Waters, E., & Wall, S. (1978). Patterns of attachment: A psychological study of the strange situation. Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
Bowlby, J. (1982). Attachment and loss: Vol. 1. Attachment (2nd ed.). Basic Books.
Freud, S. (1955). Beyond the pleasure principle. In J. Strachey (Ed. & Trans.), The standard edition of the complete psychological works of Sigmund Freud (Vol. 18, pp. 7–64). Hogarth Press. (Original work published 1920)
Main, M., & Solomon, J. (1990). Procedures for identifying infants as disorganized/disoriented during the Ainsworth Strange Situation. In M. T. Greenberg, D. Cicchetti, & E. M. Cummings (Eds.), Attachment in the preschool years: Theory, research, and intervention (pp. 121–160). University of Chicago Press.
Mikulincer, M., & Shaver, P. R. (2016). Attachment in adulthood: Structure, dynamics, and change (2nd ed.). Guilford Press.
Rogers, C. R. (1957). The necessary and sufficient conditions of therapeutic personality change. Journal of Consulting Psychology, 21(2), 95–103.
Wallin, D. J. (2007). Attachment in psychotherapy. Guilford Press.



Comments